Thread by @LeKeiby, Since there are only two chapters until the end, I thought it [...]

Since there are only two chapters until the end, I thought it would be cool to recall all the elements which lead to Eren being the father of Historia's child so here we go ! #erehisu

Isayama has always taught us not to take everything as an absolute truth, the greatest example being that mankind had perished behind walls and has always made sure that this kind of truth would be questioned.

In chapter 108, we learn from high-ranking military police that Historia became pregnant, except that the first thing that makes us question ourselves is that Roeg stipulates that they are not married.

Then they go on to tell us that the father is a farmer who only has a history of throwing rocks at the queen and has since tried to make up for it (perfect as a decoy since he has no military background).

They go on by saying someone must have warned Historia of their plan of making her the beast titan, probably Yelena, and that she decided to get pregnant to save time.

But what about all this news today? They turned out to be all wrong.
We learn in chapter 130 that it was Eren who warned her of the police plan, even more intriguing,

we also learn that Zeke and his allies had already made the army high-ranking officers ingest his cerebro-spinal fluid so Historia didn't need to get pregnant and in the end it wasn't even Eren who proposed the child but Historia.

Of all this, how can we not question if the farmer is really the father if everything that has been said is revealed to be false?

Continuing to analyze, you learn that Eren started taking unauthorized actions 10 months ago, so he met Historia 10 months ago before he left for Marley.

You'll tell me okay so what? You should know that a pregnancy in Japan is not 9 months but 10 months, which is consistent with the secret meeting of Eren and Historia.

Basically, they are trying to make us believe that Eren met Historia and the two of them agreed that she would go to the farmer to randomly ask him to have intercourse with her and all of this while Eren was watching.

It seems absurd we agree, it's in total contradiction with Eren who for 4 years has been doing everything to protect her and has even proposed to Historia to fight the police but it's also in total contradiction with the development of Historia,

the fact of living her life with pride as Ymir advised her. All the characters remain true to their nature, Eren with his freedom, Hange with his optimistic altruism, Erwin remains the big gambler he was until the end, Kenny with his lust of power,

Freckles Ymir and her selfless personnality etc, so why should Historia be the only one to contradict herself.
Last point, it is in total contradiction with the message of the manga that we saw through Grisha, Zeke, Historia and even Eren.

We must not burden future generations with the burdens of the parents, if the child is only a plan of Historia and Eren, then the child is only a tool and they repeat the mistakes of their parents. SnK's main theme is surpassing its parents.

Historia would only reproduce what her mother did with her, have a child for ulterior motives, but it doesn't fit because it's at the end of the manga. Isayama wouldn't stop his manga on this note.

We learn from Levi that Historia is supposed to give birth in a few months (3-4 months). Levi is not stupid, he knows that a pregnancy lasts 10 months.

And even if he doesn't know how many times lasts a pregnancy he must just have gotten a report from the higher ups stipulating she's going to give birth in a few months. This kind of informations are there as facts, when mangakas make their characters say things like that,

you are not supposed to say "how does he know, that's not in his character", the character is just here to convey infiormation.

Anyway, Historia is giving birth, you'll tell me that the 3-4 months have passed, but actually no since we learn that the surprise attack on Shinganshina is taking place 3 weeks - 1 month after the attack on Liberio.

What does this mean? That Historia also lied about when she became pregnant. Why would she lie about that if she didn't have something to hide?

« How can you say historia liked farmer or not?, We didn't have historia's pov. »
They didn't get married in ten months ? That's the proof, nothing more. Isayama has shown us twice that marriage is an important thing in the story.

Before having his sons, Grisha got married everytime before conceiving them.
Yes, they could've fallen in love during the ten months even if it wasn't the case when they had sex but then the same question remains: why didn't they get married ?

That would've avoided the mps suspicions and imagine a royal wedding. That would've definitly cheered up paradisians. Your queen is getting married and even has a child on the way, that means she is not disturbed by the threat posed by Marley,

that the government is doing a good job and that the island is safe. I don't even know if the population knows about Historia's pregnancy, I think they don't actually know now that I'm thinking about it.

"Do you really think she would've had a kid with a man who she knew was going to die?"
Yes ?? I hate when people say this, during WWII, people were having kids before going to war so they could leave a gift to the world and their wives. That would totally fit Eren's personnality,

he who thinks being alive is the greatest gift you can get. And you don't use common sense when you want a child, it's just natural, you want it, it doesn't need explanations, it's a feeling, maybe caused by our instincts who knows, but it's still a feeling.

Mothers feel like they are ready to have a child, so they have one. Period.

Eren is the only person who cared about Historia post timeskip, going so far as proposing to fight the mps for her and doing the rumbling later (I'm not saying Eren did the Rumbling just for this reason).

It's obvious Eren was visiting her often since he didn't have the authorization to be near the volunteers. You can see he wasn't even there when the 104th scouts tried sea food for the first time.

Where do you think he was ? Getting bored alone in his house during the whole day? No, at these times, he must've gone to Historia's farm to discuss.

Isayama doesn't even need to say "LOOK THEY ARE IN LOVE" because he did a 3years timeskip, he can do everything he wants to justify how they became close during the timeskip.

We can also talk about chapter 121, did you all see how desperate Eren was to catch Ymir even though he knew he was going to get the Founder at some point ? Even if Ymir removes the ability to reproduce to her subjects, Eren can simply undo it after ? So why ?

Because Eren saw the future until a certain point and doesn't know if the child is okay in the future since he didn't see that far. If Ymir would've removed the ability to reproduce to eldians, Historia could've had a miscarriage.

So even if Eren isn't the father it's obvious that the kid wasn't made for a plan but that Historia wanted it. But you want me to believe that a child that Historia wanted so bad wasn't made out of love but that she used a man just to have her kid ?

I prefer to believe for now that she had a kid with a man who fought for her until now and is the only one to understand her at this point of the story instead of a stranger to whom we never saw the face.

We can also talk about it, if the farmer is relevant, why does he still have no face and no name? Niccolo had a face, even the yeagerists who helped Eren and gave him his coat had faces but the man of litterally the most important girl from season 3 doesn't have a face?

If Isayama wanted to do something with this character (I don't know maybe say that hatred can be overthrown by love and Historia was strong enough to let a chance to the farmer who was bullying her when they were younger or say that no matter how big the social class is,

love can go beyond all that), he would've given a name and a face to him. So Isayama doesn't plan anything for him if litterally 5 chapters before the end he still doesn't bother giving him a face.

Isayama did everything he could to make us doubt, if Eren is not the father I will look like a big fool and I will be more surprised that if he is not than the other way around.

So here are the hints, have a good day yall!!! #erehisu

Latest Threads Unrolled: