1/

There's a bunch of different black pills that members of my tribe and adjacent tribes are tempted to take.

One is "the game is all over, the commies won."

Friend, censoring dissident voices, building walls, and lying about everything is not what winning looks like.
2/

That's what terminal rot looks like.

When the Soviet Union was rolling out rural electrification and sending the barefoot sons of farmers to study math and engineering, they didn't HAVE to lie about change and growth

The lies started later, when growth dropped to or below 0
3/

Compare the Soviet Union in 1955 to 1975 or 85. In 55 there were lots of true believers.

The Berlin Wall didn't go up the day WWII ended.

It went up 16 years later.

For 16 years, the story that "Communism is better" was plausible enough that they didn't NEED a wall.
4/

The American Cathedral didn't NEED to censor people say "the election was stolen" in 1976, because no one was credibly saying such a thing, and everyone believed in the basic morality of the Other Party.
5/

The urge to censor, to crush, to humiliate, to silence ... that's not an urge that a strong, stable, self-evidently successful government needs to indulge in.
6/

So I don't worry that "they've won, for all time, and our side will never get a nostril above water again".

This is the death throws of liberalism.

We all know that the word "liberal" originally meant "in favor of freedoms", and look how far the brand has mutated.
7/

We've gone from "The radical free speech movement" 50 years ago to "people voicing their opinions via a podcast is a 'loophole' that must be shut down."

This is an ideology that's run out of all successes, all ability to persuade with results.
8/

But that's not the PARTICULAR blank pill I want to address today.

Today's ani-venom is aimed at a different poison: the poison that "but the American PEOPLE have gone soft and are in love with communism".
9/

And, yes, many have, and it's pathetic.

But it's a Generations theory thing. These poor bastards were raised in an environment suffused with feminism, lies about the utility of liberal arts education, incompetent leaders who simultaneously told everyone to go to college >
10/

AND helped created sufficient supply of loans for college by promising lendors that the loans were not dischargeable in bankruptcy.

This generation of communists was shafted by a generation of incompetents (Biden, etc.) and they grew up blinded, punched in the head
11/

and LIED TO about who was doing the punching.

Are they soft? Yes.

Are they pathetic? Yes.

Were they actually screwed by factors outside their control? Absolutely.

Will this phenomena continue in perpetuity? Absolutely not.
12/

But even THAT is not the primary antivenom I want to share today.

Today's antivenom is that we are living through the death of the Westphalian system.

You complain to me "but half of my countrymen are communists".

I say to you "no. You are not a citizen of USG >>>
13/

you are a citizen of a new, secret country that is being given birth right before your eyes.

This country does not [ yet ] control territory. It does not [ yet ] have beautiful buildings made out of marble and granite. It does not [ yet ] have a flag.
14/

And this country, the one that's being born, this country without a name, is going to be far stronger and far more powerful than the US ever was.

Heck, it already is.

Let me explain what this country is and who the citizens are >>>
15/

Our tribe is tempted to say things like "ah, 1789 America, those were my people."

That's a country of about 3 million people, and actually you would have hated 1/3 or 1/2 of them. Puritan scolds from Harvard whipping people for disrespecting their orthodoxies.
16/

Tidewater bullies, whipping slaves and fighting dogs for fun. Scots Irish idiots, doing Scots Irish idiot things.

You can paint a [ fake ] rosy picture of the era, but the truth is that only a fraction of those people were our tribe.

Maybe 1 million of us back then.
17/

1945, tho - that was REAL America, right? GIs , gun ho, get stuff done! 139 million of us back then.

Except...again, I don't think you can count all of those people are True Americans / our tribe. These people had just voted for FDR two or three dozen times,
18/

believed in Big Government heard and soul, etc. They were more than happy to herd American citizens into camps based on ancestry. The excesses of government-run Jim Crow were everywhere.

H L Mencken, Laura Ingalls Wilder, that whole crowd - those were the DISSIDENTS.
19/

This was before the 1960s push for more free speech (which I strongly defend).

So of the 139 US citizens in 1945, how many were "our tribe" ?

I'm guessing 1/4 or so.

So the population of our tribe was maybe 35 M back then.
20/

2021 - how big is Our Tribe now? I think it's still about 1/4 of the US population ... which makes it 82 million people.

...but now we've got connectivity. A tribe is defined not just by shared characteristics, but by shared culture and connectivity.

Our tribe >>>
21/

In South Africa, Russia, Germany, Japan, Australia, Chile - all over.

I don't think there are 82 million people in this New Country Without a Name - I think there are more like 150 or 200 million.

That's still a huge minority of the Earth's population ... but it's big.
22/

Our tribe includes people building spaceships and people building alternative crypto currencies. It has randos hacking the vaccine distribution network to create better efficiencies, and it has classical artists improving the aesthetics of the world. It has authors & moms.
23/

The New Country Without a Name is hard to see, because we were all raised in the Westphalian System and we don't yet have words for such things, or eyes to see it.

But look around your twitter mutuals These are the patriots of the new country.
24/

My friend @skiballar once said "I realized that I'm a patriot of a country that never really existed".

I'm going to turn that around.

"I've realized that I'm a patriot of a company that doesn't yet [ fully ] exist."
25/

The Cathedral can [ and will ] try to push us underground, but they're working off a broken and outdated model. They think that they're preserving their own decaying incompetent kleptocracy which is based on geographic borders.

...but what they're actually doing is >
26/

telling the competent, the truthful, the unintimidated, the skillful, the prudent, the brave, the family creators: "This society has no place for you. You don't belong here. You're not One of Us."

I agree with them!

The Bidens, the AOCs, the Kamalas - they're right.
27/

They're 100% right.
28/

The USG is a quarter millennium old pile of garbage with a veneer of marble and red-white-and-blue bunting, wrapped in a rainbow flag, decorated with anti-intellectual "tRuSt tHe sCiEncE" propaganda posters.

It can't launch a spaceship.

It can't distribute a vaccine.
29/

It can't prevent Great Power infiltration and subversion.

It can't secure its borders.

It can't rig an election well enough to convince people.

It can't convince its citizens, so it has to silence them.
30/

Moldbug is right that we should not take up arms against this gray, incompetent, Brezhnevite joke of a regime.

...but I don't think he's right that we should wait for Emperor Thiel to free us.

I think that's still 19th century thinking.
31/

The new world that I see being born is spread across the Earth, and is in orbit, is on the moon and Mars, and elsewhere.

...and the nations and tribes of that new world are not crisply geographically distinct.

We live in a privileged time. We're witnessing great things
32/

About once every 500 years the world changes fundamentally.

~ 0 AD: the birth of a new kind of administrative state [ Rome ] and a new religion that was supportive of individuals [ Christianity ]
33/

~ 500 AD: birth of post-Roman world, integration of administration & German tribal democracy

~ 1,000 AD: formalization of the above, developments in art, philosophy, some tech

~ 1,500 AD the Enlightenment, Industrial Revolution precursor
34/

End of the ~500 year run of the Westphalian system, beginning of something new.

Neal Stephenson had more than a small glimpse of this, with his neo-Victorians.
35/

Nothing build on a lie can long survive, and can never thrive.

The Cathedral system is built on SOOOO many lies:

* credential education, even in made up nit wit topics, is good

* family is meaningless, children are bad

* "merit" and "intelligence" are fake concepts
36/

I could go down the list, but you know all the lies that we're all being asked to believe. You know all of the pinches of incense that we're being asked to burn for Caesar.
37/

So what is this New Invisible Country?

More or less the inverse of all of that

* Competence is real.
* Results matter.
* Credentials don't.
* Social lies are laughable.
* Moral bravery matters; following the latest trends is actively bad
* Family, marriage, children matter
38/

* Free speech is good.
* Rights are real.
* Producing value isn't the ONLY thing in life, but it's an important thing.
* Piety and decency matter.
* Western civilization has more good than bad.
* People who are willing to accept our culture are welcome to join our project
39/

I could go on and on, but lunch is on the table.

TLDR: don't despair because the old corrupt system is failing; rejoice because we few, we happy few, we band of brothers, are building a new nation, right under their eyes.

And we're succeeding.
40/

Yep.

TFW "there's a lot of ruin in a nation" means that the boss villain has far more hitpoints than you'd hope. https://twitter.com/drethelin/status/1351225761655623683
41/

The arc of things in the long run is good.

The arc of things over the next 20-30 years is chaotic AF. https://twitter.com/OrneryThe8th/status/1351229897222606857
42/

If you liked my white-pill thread about how Our Tribe is gonna win in the end, you might be interested in some novels I wrote on the same topic. https://twitter.com/MorlockP/status/1303047090399055875
43/

Can you imagine Reagan and the entire Republican party in 1981 trying to regulate 'zines out of existence, because mimeographed newsletters about music and anarchism were a threat to the powers that be?

No.

And yet here we are, 40 years later. https://twitter.com/Holbornlolz/status/1351243262212902915
44/

relevant to this thread https://twitter.com/TheAgeofShoddy/status/1351245643331862532
45/

Sure. I like "phyle" a bit better, and that's the one I use in Aristillus 3 and 4 ... which I intend to get back to as soon as Escape the City ships. https://twitter.com/Atrosto/status/1351287702214242307
46/

(a) Amazing. Congrats, UK, on a great policy decision.

(b) this is what the new post-Westphalian world looks like. Charter cities, exclaves, expats with citizenship in place A but residence in place B ... https://twitter.com/mattwridley/status/1351531363997020164
47/

I think I've muted like 5 doomers already today.

Ahead of schedule, for 9:58 am, but way below quota for the day.

Muting people is great technology - it's shaping the social graph ... which is a key part of defining and building the new tribe / phyle / distributed nation.
48/

Aphorism: whether you think you can, or you think you can't, you're right.
49/

Parable:

a man came to the city gate and asked the guard "what are the people like in this city?". The guard answered with a question "what are they like in YOUR city?".

The man replied "they are liars, cheats, and thieves"

Guard: "you will find this city much the same"
50/

a second man came to the city gate and asked the guard "what are the people like in this city?". The guard answered with a question "what are they like in YOUR city?".

The man replied "they are kind, helpful, and honest"

Guard: "you will find this city much the same".
51/

The hilarious thing about these griefers, these doomsters, is that when they assert "no, no, the communists have won, and things won't get better ever, or if they do, not in our lifetimes!!!" ... they're showing that they're not really opposed to the communists. >
52/

They're co-dependent.

They want the emotional certainty that doom is everywhere, that hard work shouldn't be attempted, because it's pointless.

Risk scares them.

Work scares them.

Being an adult scares them.
53/

A doomster approaches the New Country that is being born, and asks the guard "is hard work rewarded in this new country? is giving a damn worth it in this new country?"

guard: what did you do back in the US?

doomster: I whined & complained

guard: I would do the same here
54/

A True American approaches the New Country and asks the guard "is hard work rewarded in this new country? is giving a damn worth it in this new country?"

guard: what did you do back in the US?

patriot: I took risks, worked hard, and stood on my own feet.

guard: welcome !
55/

and the gate to the New Country was opened for him.
56/

121 followers.

Never fails.

This New Country isn't for you, @lost_gothi . Best of luck elsewhere.
57/

Great poem, but I've highlighted my favorite part.

Hard work, even ( especially !) in face of adversity is what makes one a Man, my son!

Doomsters hate this one secret.
58/

TY!

I think we've been seeing this new world slowly coalesce for 20+ years already.

It may take another 30, 50, or 130 until it's fully fledged.

Gutenberg press (1440) -> US Declaration of Independence (1776) took some time. https://twitter.com/MogTheUrbanite/status/1351550172258451459
59/ https://twitter.com/skiballar/status/1351553172834279424
60/
61/

One of the most encouraging things about this thread is that I've been getting RTs in Spanish, DMs from Austrians and Swedes, etc.

This new Secret Country, this Distributed Republic, is more American than not, but it knows no geographic borders or racial lines. >
62/

The communists tell us that this terrible thing called "whiteness" believes in merit, hard work, schedules, just deserts, and more.

I disagree with two things:
* that there's anything "white" about that. This is a set of ideas, not a skin color.
* that it's terrible.
63/

Some of my best friends in this tribe, this new Secret Country, are white, Anglo, and their families have been in the New World for 300+ years.

...but others were born in Mexico, Africa, Taiwan, and other places.

I'm not saying that the Brexit folks in the UK, or >
64/

the Mouvement des gilets jaunes in France, or Bolsonaroism or r various other movements in other areas are the exact same thing as MAGA ... but there is some overlap of the sets.

There are people world-wide who resent the incompetent credentialed elites sneering at them >
65/

Indeed, I'm sure that there are huge disconnects between a random MAGA person and a random Gilets Jaunes. My point is not that this is one big movement. My point is that in the 21st century, geography cuts at 90 degrees to ideology.
66/

Sometimes I look around the hideously divided US, where the two sides literally fantasize about murdering each other, and literally fear that they will be murdered in turn ... and think about what it might be like to be a member of a small 5 or 15 million person country
67/

where there are domestic politics, to be sure. That prime minister, he's so corrupt! And his brother in the Water Authority - an arrogant SOB. He should be voted out!

...but wouldn't it be great to think of these people are YOUR bastards? You and the other 10 million >
68/

at least agreeing on core things, like the fact that the national dish of fried-whatever-in-whatever-sauce is delicious? That the traditional folk music is wonderful? That the land you share is the most beautiful in the world? That all of the outsiders are sad bc >
69/

They didn't have the good luck to be born HERE, to be part of THIS wonderful little culture?

That's what I imagine we're going to see 50-150 years from now.

Lots of little tribes / phyles / polities, each with their own norms, traditions, and values.
70/

Will there be dissidents? Of course! And in a sane world, dissidents will do what they've always done - find their own kind.

The current Westphalian system is a legacy of expensive travel, non existent communication, poor sorting.
71/

I look forward to the future where our tribe, of 70 or 170 or 270 million, selected not by accident of birth location, but by belief in hard work, family, equality before the law, the right to make one's own mistakes, the right to worship God (or not), can stand on its feet.
72/

Welcome to the New Country. https://twitter.com/MogTheUrbanite/status/1351932617004781573
74/

> What might these reverse diasporas be like? As a people whose primary bond is through internet, many of their properties would not fit our pre-existing mental models... these emigrants would be moving within or between nation states to become part of a community

yes.jpg
You can follow @MorlockP.
Tip: mention @twtextapp on a Twitter thread with the keyword “unroll” to get a link to it.

Latest Threads Unrolled:

By continuing to use the site, you are consenting to the use of cookies as explained in our Cookie Policy to improve your experience.