the difference between orientalism, middle eastern culture & islam.

a thread
Orientalism is the imitation or depiction of aspects in the eastern world. These depictions are commonly seen in hollywood movies, taking place in the middle east and showing a culture, that doesn’t even fit the picture in real life. in edward said’s study about orientalism +
+ he refers to general patronizing of Western attitude towards Middle Eastern, being static and undeveloped; because they want to show the idea that Western society is developed, rational, flexible, and superior. that is not the case in this mv. In fact, there isn’t any+
+depiction of negativity towards any society in the mv. They wear baggy pants, commonly seen in villages all over the world, not just muslim countries (known as shalvar) even in modern fashion, bc it isn’t secured by any patent whatsoever. it’s clothing.
Considering the magic
in the mv you clearly see a dance around fire known for devilish sorcery & then disappearances by some kind of obvious magic. the practice of magic has no place in islam. “Practicing magic is an act of disbelief.[Quran 2:102]” hence the theme of the mv clearly shifts to fantasy.
the title being “make a wish” is also an opposition to islam because making dua/prayer to God instead of wishes, is being highlighted many times by the teachings of prophet (pbuh), hence making wishes doesn’t allude to islam at all. in fact, the title delimits itself from islam.
Considering the fact that they put their hands together is again marking this theme off from islam, because that is not how prayer is being taught by islamic teachings.
considering the architecture you have to draw the line between mv and the stage performance, because on stage you can indeed see the tombstone of the prophet’s grandson, WHICH IS WHY SM NEEDS TO APOLOGIZE. the boys have nothing to do with it though they might be forced to shut up
The common doors and entrances in the middle east are prior to the birth of islam. In fact they are traced back to the time of prophet moses (pbuh) hence, being used in hebrew culture, wandering through the region from arabia up to north africa, persia and the byzantine empire.
If the hexagon (seen many times in the mv) should bother someone, it should be christians. As a matter of fact, the hexagon is used by romans 36BC and adapted into christianity as a symbol for the creation of the world in 6 days. Hexagon is used all over the world &isn’t culture.
The architecture of the kaabah is not seen anywhere in the mv. But if the oriental symbols and geometry still bother you, although we now clearly see that this mv isn’t alluding to islam in any ways, let’s take a step back and look where the real +
+ problem with orientalism and negative portrayals of islam take place.
I’m saddened that most muslims on twt do not report nct because they feel attacked by the mv, BUT because they have other issues regarding sm/nct. You might also consider the fact that stanning men you aren’t married to, is a debated topic in islam ;) so you might think twice +
+ about what it even means to do the right thing. Of course faith is everyone’s private business, I myself am a practicing muslim, but that being said, nobody’s perfect. I wish and pray that one day yall muslim twt stans also protect and support islam like this when it really +
+ matters. not because of kpop or some entertainment/management messing up the theme. it’s nice to see that yall have a voice and know how you might use it. So use it for the oppressed ones.
also I am muslim since birth, I have my bachelor & masters degree for orientalism, arabistic, islamic studies and english studies from a german university. I speak german, english, arabic, turkish, italian, french & a lil korean. I’m open for news agencies or any questions in dm.
You can follow @xuxidimples.
Tip: mention @twtextapp on a Twitter thread with the keyword “unroll” to get a link to it.

Latest Threads Unrolled:

By continuing to use the site, you are consenting to the use of cookies as explained in our Cookie Policy to improve your experience.