I restarted Red Dead Redemption 2 a few days ago and I'm still not back to where I was before. It's so easy to make big mistake at some points so I keep having to reload. Bullseye, my horse just died because she was following me up a steep mountain to find treasure and fell.

I think you can revive your horses but she fell too far too fast for me to climb down after her. I spent like 10 minutes riding out there, damn it!
I accidentally drew my gun on a lady I rescued from some lawmen. They were carting her off to prison and she was claiming she had to kill a man or he would kill her. You bet I broke her out but I pressed L2 at the wrong time and scared her away after. The guilt still consumes me!
LOL just fell off the same cliff myself.