Read on Twitter
Thread :
The Government Of India Has Passed Three Controversial Farms Bills To Change The Shape Of Agriculture Sector , Remember Not Just Farmers Even Common Men Will Also Get Affected By These Bills In One Or Other Way ,Let Me Evaluate All Three Bills Below
N/1
The Government Of India Has Passed Three Controversial Farms Bills To Change The Shape Of Agriculture Sector , Remember Not Just Farmers Even Common Men Will Also Get Affected By These Bills In One Or Other Way ,Let Me Evaluate All Three Bills Below
N/1
The First Bill "The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement On Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill 2020
This Bill Will Introduce Contract Farming Between Buyers & Farmers ,Farmers Will Produce Crops As Per Agreement ,Even Price Would Be Decided In Agreement
N/2
This Bill Will Introduce Contract Farming Between Buyers & Farmers ,Farmers Will Produce Crops As Per Agreement ,Even Price Would Be Decided In Agreement
N/2
Now If Farmers Failed To Produce The Quality Crops Decided As Per Agreements Them Buyer(Company) May Refuse To Purchase That Crops !
And It's Impossible To Meet All The Standard Because Rain/Drought Etc May Affect Crops
Then What Remedy Farmers Have If Company Refused ?
N/3
And It's Impossible To Meet All The Standard Because Rain/Drought Etc May Affect Crops
Then What Remedy Farmers Have If Company Refused ?
N/3
If Company or Buyer Refused To Purchased Due To Breach Of Contract, Then ?
The Farmers May Approach Before SDM Or DC Or They May Refer Application Before Reconsideration Board !
Remember These Courts Are Not Independent ,Why Civil Court Has No Power To Entertain The Case ?
N/4
The Farmers May Approach Before SDM Or DC Or They May Refer Application Before Reconsideration Board !
Remember These Courts Are Not Independent ,Why Civil Court Has No Power To Entertain The Case ?
N/4
Two Main Drawback Are :
If Company Goes Bankrupts Like Vijay Malya Or Nirav Then Who Will Compensate The Farmers ?
Why Civil Court Has No Jurisdiction To Entertain The Case Under The Said Act ?
Government Just Waving It's Liability From Agriculture Sector
That's It
N/5
If Company Goes Bankrupts Like Vijay Malya Or Nirav Then Who Will Compensate The Farmers ?
Why Civil Court Has No Jurisdiction To Entertain The Case Under The Said Act ?
Government Just Waving It's Liability From Agriculture Sector
That's It
N/5
The Another Bill Passed By The Government Is "The Essential Commodities (Amendment)Bill ,2020
What Was The Needs To Bring This Bills ?
Why Even Government Brought It In July Amid Pandemic ?
Need To Understand The Bill ,This Bill Will Affect Everyone Whether Farmer Or Not
N/6
What Was The Needs To Bring This Bills ?
Why Even Government Brought It In July Amid Pandemic ?
Need To Understand The Bill ,This Bill Will Affect Everyone Whether Farmer Or Not
N/6
The Essential Commodities Are Need Of Everyone & Everyday ,Like Edibles Oils ,Pulses ,Potatos Etc ,These Price Were Regulated By The Government ,No One Was Allowed to Hoarding & Black Marketing To Surge The Price !
There Was No Need Of This Law, Existing System Was Best
N/7
There Was No Need Of This Law, Existing System Was Best
N/7
Drawback : Now Government Will Not Regulate The Price Of Essential Goods And Traders Can Hoard The Goods Except In Case Of Femine /Draught /War Etc
Now There Is No Check On Hoarding So Price May Be Surge By Seller By Many Means
This Is Against Everyone If Understand
N/8
Now There Is No Check On Hoarding So Price May Be Surge By Seller By Many Means
This Is Against Everyone If Understand
N/8
Another Bill " The Farming Produce Trade &Commerce (Promotion And Facilitation ) Bill 2020
Now As Per This Bill Farmers May Sell His Crops Anywhere But Before Now Too There Were No Restrictions On Inter State Or Intra State Trades
Why This Bill ?
N/9
Now As Per This Bill Farmers May Sell His Crops Anywhere But Before Now Too There Were No Restrictions On Inter State Or Intra State Trades
Why This Bill ?
N/9
Drawabcak :
It may eventually end the MSP-based procurement system.
* Electronic trading like in e-NAM uses physical 'mandi' structure. What will happen to e-NAM if 'mandis' are destroyed in absence of trading?
And Scrapping OF Mandi Will Leave Many Unemployed
N/10
It may eventually end the MSP-based procurement system.
* Electronic trading like in e-NAM uses physical 'mandi' structure. What will happen to e-NAM if 'mandis' are destroyed in absence of trading?
And Scrapping OF Mandi Will Leave Many Unemployed
N/10
These Bills Passed By Central Government !
Madhya Pardesh & Haryana Also Ruled By BJP !
PM : Any Farmers May Sell There Crops Anywhere
CM's : We Will Not Allow Anyone To Sell There Crops In Our States
When BJP's CM's Not Following These Bills Then Why Farmers ?
N/11
Madhya Pardesh & Haryana Also Ruled By BJP !
PM : Any Farmers May Sell There Crops Anywhere
CM's : We Will Not Allow Anyone To Sell There Crops In Our States
When BJP's CM's Not Following These Bills Then Why Farmers ?
N/11
Adani,Ambani &other corporates had an eye on massive food grain market of India.They had few problems:
Problem 1 :
States had different rules ®ulations 2buy food grains frm farmers. It was difficult 4corporates 2handle so many states with so many different regulations &taxes
Problem 1 :
States had different rules ®ulations 2buy food grains frm farmers. It was difficult 4corporates 2handle so many states with so many different regulations &taxes
Modi Solution:
Took control from states and made 1 act for whole country. Corporates happy now.
Problem 2:
Corporates will buy crops and store them. But Essential Commodity act will stop them for storing crops for long time, as it increase prices in market.
Took control from states and made 1 act for whole country. Corporates happy now.
Problem 2:
Corporates will buy crops and store them. But Essential Commodity act will stop them for storing crops for long time, as it increase prices in market.
Modi Solution:
Food crops will not come under Essential Commodity act and can be stored for longer period. Corporates again happy.
Problem 3
It was hard to determine that what type of crop will be grown by farmers.
Food crops will not come under Essential Commodity act and can be stored for longer period. Corporates again happy.
Problem 3
It was hard to determine that what type of crop will be grown by farmers.
Modi Solution:
Contract farming for farmers where they will be told by corporates to grow what kind of crop. Corporates again happy.
Problem 4 :
How Corporates will handle court cases if anything goes wrong against farmers. N/16
Contract farming for farmers where they will be told by corporates to grow what kind of crop. Corporates again happy.
Problem 4 :
How Corporates will handle court cases if anything goes wrong against farmers. N/16
Modi Solution:
Farmers can not go to courts. They will go to SDM and DC.
Corporates again happy as they can bribe them
They say bills are in favor of farmers. ....
Whoever wrote this please tell us so that we can give deserve credit.
N/17
Farmers can not go to courts. They will go to SDM and DC.
Corporates again happy as they can bribe them
They say bills are in favor of farmers. ....
Whoever wrote this please tell us so that we can give deserve credit.
N/17
