Analysis of how margin of error could have affected all 16 VAR offside decisions in the Prem.
- 5 of 14 disallowed count
- Of the 5, 3 are Liverpool
- Three could have changed result (2 Liverpool)
- Only goal allowed would be ruled out on "Umpire's Call"
A thread.
- 5 of 14 disallowed count
- Of the 5, 3 are Liverpool
- Three could have changed result (2 Liverpool)
- Only goal allowed would be ruled out on "Umpire's Call"
A thread.
To start with, if you missed it, here's yesterday's thread explaining how the Eredivisie uses margin of error on VAR offside. https://twitter.com/DaleJohnsonESPN/status/1333710559137640449?s=20
Southampton v Tottenham (Sept. 20)
Goal (scored by Harry Kane) disallowed for offside against Son Heung-Min (0-0, Spurs won 2-5)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Offside
Goal remains disallowed.
Goal (scored by Harry Kane) disallowed for offside against Son Heung-Min (0-0, Spurs won 2-5)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Offside
Goal remains disallowed.
Newcastle v Brighton (Sept. 20)
Neal Maupay goal allowed after being ruled out for offside, 8th minute (Brighton 0-1 up, finished 0-3)
VAR DECISION: Onside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Offside
Final result not affected, but Brighton would have had an onside goal remain disallowed.
Neal Maupay goal allowed after being ruled out for offside, 8th minute (Brighton 0-1 up, finished 0-3)
VAR DECISION: Onside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Offside
Final result not affected, but Brighton would have had an onside goal remain disallowed.
Brighton v Man United (Sept. 26)
Marcus Rashford goal disallowed for offside (1-1, Man United won 3-2)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Offside
Offside lines not broadcast, ahead of the ball.
Marcus Rashford goal disallowed for offside (1-1, Man United won 3-2)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Offside
Offside lines not broadcast, ahead of the ball.
Leicester v West Ham (Oct. 4)
Jamie Vardy offside in build-up to Harvey Barnes goal, 90th minute (0-3)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Onside
Final result unaffected.
Jamie Vardy offside in build-up to Harvey Barnes goal, 90th minute (0-3)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Onside
Final result unaffected.
Everton v Liverpool (Oct. 17)
Jordan Henderson goal ruled out for offside against Sadio Mane, 90th minute (2-2)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Onside
Liverpool would probably have won a game they drew 2-2.
Jordan Henderson goal ruled out for offside against Sadio Mane, 90th minute (2-2)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Onside
Liverpool would probably have won a game they drew 2-2.
Newcastle v Man United (Oct. 17)
Bruno Fernandes goal ruled out for offside against Juan Mata, 19th minute (1-0, Man United won 1-4)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Offside
Clear offside, full calibration not required.
Bruno Fernandes goal ruled out for offside against Juan Mata, 19th minute (1-0, Man United won 1-4)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Offside
Clear offside, full calibration not required.
Leeds v Wolves (Oct. 19)
Goal for Romain Saiss disallowed for offside in the build-up by Daniel Podence, 54th minute (0-0, Wolves won 0-1)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Offside
Clear offside, full calibration not required.
Goal for Romain Saiss disallowed for offside in the build-up by Daniel Podence, 54th minute (0-0, Wolves won 0-1)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Offside
Clear offside, full calibration not required.
Liverpool v Sheffield United (Oct. 24)
Mohamed Salah goal disallowed for offside, 62nd minute (1-1, Liverpool won 2-1)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Onside
Final result not affected.
Mohamed Salah goal disallowed for offside, 62nd minute (1-1, Liverpool won 2-1)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Onside
Final result not affected.
Wolves v Crystal Palace (Oct. 30)
Penalty for Crystal Palace cancelled for offside against Patrick van Aanholt, 38th minute (Wolves 2-0)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Offside
Clear offside, full calibration not required.
Penalty for Crystal Palace cancelled for offside against Patrick van Aanholt, 38th minute (Wolves 2-0)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Offside
Clear offside, full calibration not required.
Southampton v Villa (Nov. 1)
Ezri Konsa own goal disallowed for offside against Che Adams, 3rd minute (0-0, finished 3-4)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Offside
Goal remains disallowed.
Ezri Konsa own goal disallowed for offside against Che Adams, 3rd minute (0-0, finished 3-4)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Offside
Goal remains disallowed.
Crystal Palace v Leeds (Nov. 7)
Patrick Bamford goal disallowed for offside, 19th minute (1-0, finished 4-1)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Onside
Early in game so possible result changer.
Patrick Bamford goal disallowed for offside, 19th minute (1-0, finished 4-1)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Onside
Early in game so possible result changer.
Arsenal v Aston Villa (Nov. 8)
John McGinn goal disallowed for offside against Ross Barkley, 1st minute (0-0, finished 0-3)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Offside
Goal remains disallowed.
John McGinn goal disallowed for offside against Ross Barkley, 1st minute (0-0, finished 0-3)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Offside
Goal remains disallowed.
Man City v Burnley (Nov. 28)
Bailey Peacock-Farrell own goal disallowed for offside in the build-up against Gabriel Jesus, 77th minute (5-0)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Offside
Goal remains disallowed. Lines do not touch.
Bailey Peacock-Farrell own goal disallowed for offside in the build-up against Gabriel Jesus, 77th minute (5-0)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Offside
Goal remains disallowed. Lines do not touch.
Brighton v Liverpool (Nov. 28)
Mohamed Salah goal disallowed for offside, 35th minute (0-0, finished 1-1)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Onside
Was 0-0 at the time, so result could have been affected.
Mohamed Salah goal disallowed for offside, 35th minute (0-0, finished 1-1)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Onside
Was 0-0 at the time, so result could have been affected.
Brighton v Liverpool (Nov. 28)
Offside against Sadio Mane after scoring, 85th minute (0-1, finished 1-1)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Offside
Clear offside, full calibration not required.
Offside against Sadio Mane after scoring, 85th minute (0-1, finished 1-1)
VAR DECISION: Offside
WITH MARGIN OF ERROR: Offside
Clear offside, full calibration not required.