#SCOTUS now hearing arguments on #ACA challenge. DOJ shifted positions, will argue that the individual mandate is unconstitutional & the Court should invalidate entire ACA. The implications are deadly, millions of people would lose health coverage. Trump never had a backup plan.
So far Court is laser-focused on standing.
Listen to arguments here: https://www.c-span.org/video/?471185-1/health-care-law-supreme-court-oral-argument
Solicitor General Wall arguing against a federal statute-opposite of SG’s normal job of defending federal law. SG also has to perform some gymnastics to justify standing by TX and states challenging ACA
Sotomayor: if Congress had simply phased out the mandate penalty over time instead of immediately zeroing it out, wouldn't that be a valid exercise of the tax power? Wall: Yes.
This is problematic for US and TX position that entire ACA needs to be invalidated.
This is problematic for US and TX position that entire ACA needs to be invalidated.
And that’s a wrap. It appears there are 5 votes to find mandate unconstitutional but not 5 to find mandate inseverable, which would leave #ACA mostly in tact.