I think that this Q&A with Sir David King, chair of UKs Independent SAGE sums up the end game of such an initiative. https://www.independentsage.org/qa-with-sir-david-king-chair-of-independent-sage/
When asked why he felt the need to set up the Independent SAGE since the government already had its own advisory body, SAGE, to deal with emergencies, he answered:
âBecause there is no transparency about what the government is doing, no open discussion whatsoever.â
âBecause there is no transparency about what the government is doing, no open discussion whatsoever.â
âAt the start of the pandemic, the membership of SAGE and the minutes of its meetings were kept secret. During our first public meeting in May, the minutes of SAGEâs first six meetings and the list of members were published with a few redactions...â
â... (Dominic Cummingsâ name was removed). We embarrassed them into going public.â
A key part of Independent SAGEâs mission statement is making scientific expertise accessible to the public. Why is this so important?
âFirst of all you have to bring together the right group of experts to give advice on how to handle an emergency.â
âFirst of all you have to bring together the right group of experts to give advice on how to handle an emergency.â
âBut the most important thing we do is to have open, public meetings. We produce draft reports before those meetings and then we change the reports based on the to and from between the public and the experts. â
âFor the experts to hear what the public have got to say is absolutely critical and in that process youâre improving the advice youâre giving to the government.â
âBut thereâs something else very important that youâre doing â youâre gaining the trust of the public and thatâs what the government has failed to do completely.â
A very important point is that inevitably, some or all advice will be ignored by the government. To this, Sir David King says: âThere was a point earlier in the year when we were saying, âUse the summer to manage this epidemic, try to get down to zero Covid, ...â
â... with a fully operative Find, Test, Trace & Isolate systemâ, because we knew that the winter months were going to be really difficult, and the advice was ignored and here we are going into a second wave. It is incredibly frustrating but we have to just carry on.â
âIn each case Iâve always told my colleagues âDonât look backwards, weâve got to take where we are today and give the best possible advice going forwardsâ.â
And about the fact that a short term enterprise is still needed months into the pandemic: âWe didnât expect that we would still be needed after three months, but here we are. Iâm extraordinarily proud of this group of people, who are all world experts in their fields. â
âThey all have tough day jobs and the work they have put into Independent SAGE has been quite remarkable and they are not paid a bean for it. But itâs a question of public responsibility. â
âWe will keep going until we feel that our advice has been taken and as a result the disease has stopped spreading. We will keep going until there is an end in sight and that end has to be a zero Covid Britain.â