I think some people seem to deliberetly misunderstand or misrepresent my position on modern-Who. So let me make it quite clear;
There is nothing inherently wrong with disliking the current run.
However, if that dislike is rooted in bigotry and you spread lies...that's not good.
There is nothing inherently wrong with disliking the current run.
However, if that dislike is rooted in bigotry and you spread lies...that's not good.
Good: 'Orphan 55' was over-stuffed, looked cheap, oddly paced etc.
Bad: New-Who is bad because too many Muslims! Every villain is a white man! Woke agenda! Jodie said she hates men!
I don't want to act as an authority on "good criticism" but surely you can tell the difference.
Bad: New-Who is bad because too many Muslims! Every villain is a white man! Woke agenda! Jodie said she hates men!
I don't want to act as an authority on "good criticism" but surely you can tell the difference.
What fundamentally frustrates me about NMD is that there ARE issues with the current run. I have reviews/reactions on every 13th Doc story and I've levied numerous criticisms.
But they're so committed to their bigotry and narrative that those issues rarely get brought up.
But they're so committed to their bigotry and narrative that those issues rarely get brought up.
Let's say these NMD actually did care about the show and wanted it to be better.
But if I was a showrunner and saw these baseless, unhinged and frequently bigoted "criticisms" I'd ignore them.
If these people were acting in good faith (they're not) they're hurting themselves.
But if I was a showrunner and saw these baseless, unhinged and frequently bigoted "criticisms" I'd ignore them.
If these people were acting in good faith (they're not) they're hurting themselves.
Imagine if Chibnall sat down and met with these people.
Chibnall: What can we do to improve?
NMD: Why are all the villains white men!
Chibnall: They're...they're not.
NMD: You're forcing black people in the show!
Chibnall: Tosin and Mandip weren't the first...
NMD: REEEEEEE
Chibnall: What can we do to improve?
NMD: Why are all the villains white men!
Chibnall: They're...they're not.
NMD: You're forcing black people in the show!
Chibnall: Tosin and Mandip weren't the first...
NMD: REEEEEEE