[Thread]

Aryan Invasion Theory — A Response to @mkatju's Questions

A very important thread for all of you!
So Kashmunist Brahmin @mkatju writes an article on @TheWeek and asks five questions for those who debunk the Aryan Invasion Theory.

Here's the article —

https://www.theweek.in/news/india/2019/09/15/opinion-questions-for-those-who-debunk-the-aryan-invasion-theory.html
Q#1: Why are upper castes, particularly Brahmins, relatively fairer in complexion to Scheduled Castes?

A: The answer is same as why the earth is flat!

This guy Katju is himself a Nibba when compared to Persian looking Kashmiri Muslims and he asks us "why Brahmins are fairer" 🙄
To end this argument once and for all I bring a Brahmin and a Bahujan in the ground

The left pic is of Brahmin Vajpayee and right pic is of Bahujan Mayawati...

What "complexion difference" did you notice @mkatju ? Please tell me?
Q#2: Why is fair colour preferred to dark colour in India?

A: I don't know if Katju ever studied history but India was under colonial rule for 200 years. It was the racist outlook and policies of White Britishers which is responsible for this preference of fair skin
Q#3: Sanskrit, in which the Vedas were written, was found by William Jones & other scholars to have striking similarities with Greek and Latin

A: A counter question is if Greek has "striking" similarities to Sanskrit, then why Ancient Indians called Greek/Latin as मलेच्छ भाषा??
Plus isn't it interesting to note that most Greek/Latin words have their Sanskrit counterparts but MOST Sanskrit words have NO PARALLEL in these "Indo-Aryan" languages (मलेच्छ is one such word)

Also why their Grammar/Syntax is COMPLETELY DIFFERENT. Will these 'scholars' answer?
Q#4: A reading of the Rig Veda, the earliest Sanskrit text, gives the impression that a war is going on.

A: It's good to know that despite being an 'atheist' you have read the Rig Veda; but still gained no wisdom from it Mr. Kaju.

There was no 'war' going on during that time!
I don't know which Rig Veda @mkatju has read but there's no such thing there. Infact there is NO HISTORY or GEOGRAPHY in Vedas. This is the founding principle taught in every Vedic School.

All the rivers, etc were named AFTER the QUALITIES mentioned in Rigveda and not vice versa
For understanding Vedas please refer to this thread by @VedicWisdom1

In short, there are NO NOUNS in Vedas as such (except the primitive ones like man, woman, etc)

There are ONLY ADJECTIVES (for eg. Indra refers to characteristics of a King or Ruler) https://twitter.com/VedicWisdom1/status/1250857633805811713
Q#5: The word 'Ayya' in Tamil which means master, is derived from the Sanskrit word 'Arya' or Aryan. What does this insinuate?

A: This insinuates that Tamil has "striking" similarities to Sanskrit because in Sanskrit also 'Arya' means a noble person (or master in this context)
Rigveda 9.63.5 says कृण्वन्तो विश्वमार्यम् which means 'Make the whole world Arya'

So again Arya is not a noun but an adjective meaning 'noble' person or 'great' person

In Pali or Prakrit it becomes Ayya and same goes for Tamil also.
So all five questions answered by a person who debunks the Aryan Invasion Theory!

Now @mkatju you answer my five questions —

1. If Aryans came from Europe as you say @mkatju, then why is there only <5% European DNA in most Indians. Shouldn't it be as high as 60-80%??
2. On Indus Valley site we find SEVERAL seals related to Hinduism (swastika, pashupati seal, etc)

It also appears that Harrappans believed in rebirth and cows were sacred for them. The Vedas say the cow is the mother of Aryas (see Atharva XII-IV-33)

What does this insinuate?
3. Next, why is the grammar/syntax of Sanskrit and Tamil so similar? And why both languages shared the same script for thousand years? (i.e. Brahmi script)

4. If "Aryans" invaded Harrappans then with what? Chariots have been found in Bhagpath dating back to 4000 BC!
5. The Rig Veda mentions position of stars which can be used to find it's composition date astronomically. And a German scholar Jacobi arrived at the figure 6500 BC. When did Aryan Invasion Theory happen by the way?
You can follow @vedicboy.
Tip: mention @twtextapp on a Twitter thread with the keyword “unroll” to get a link to it.

Latest Threads Unrolled:

By continuing to use the site, you are consenting to the use of cookies as explained in our Cookie Policy to improve your experience.