Read on Twitter
Don't believe what they say about Calif. blackouts
They result from *political* failure to hold PG&E accountable after $21 BILLION bail-out
Failure stems from decades-long focus on climate/renewables instead of fortifying electric grid & a weak, distracted governor
THREAD https://twitter.com/ShellenbergerMD/status/1188466346675167232
They result from *political* failure to hold PG&E accountable after $21 BILLION bail-out
Failure stems from decades-long focus on climate/renewables instead of fortifying electric grid & a weak, distracted governor
THREAD https://twitter.com/ShellenbergerMD/status/1188466346675167232
As background, I have been investigating and writing on California's energy & environmental policies, including their historical roots, for the last four years
My research will be published in book form by Harper Collins next year
The story begins in the 1960s
My research will be published in book form by Harper Collins next year
The story begins in the 1960s
Back in the 1960s, PG&E & other California utilities planned to replace the burning of oil for electricity with nuclear plants
The President of Sierra Club was a humanist & conservationist who supported building nuclear plants, including Diablo Canyon http://environmentalprogress.org/big-news/2018/1/11/jerry-browns-secret-war-on-clean-energy
The President of Sierra Club was a humanist & conservationist who supported building nuclear plants, including Diablo Canyon http://environmentalprogress.org/big-news/2018/1/11/jerry-browns-secret-war-on-clean-energy
The pro-nuclear conservationists in the 1960s were opposed by two groups, anti-human Malthusian greens who opposed nuclear precisely because it was clean & abundant energy that deprived them of their power to fear-monger about resource scarcity, & state oil interests
Oil interests and anti-nuclear Malthusians joined forces under the leadership of Gov. Jerry Brown, first elected in 1974
Brown's family owned a lucrative Indonesian oil import concession
Brown's advisor & fundraiser was father of current Gov. Newsom who worked for Getty Oil
Brown's family owned a lucrative Indonesian oil import concession
Brown's advisor & fundraiser was father of current Gov. Newsom who worked for Getty Oil
As soon as he took office @JerryBrownGov took action to protect his family's oil monopoly and work to kill the building and expansion of nuclear power in California, which most threatened the wealth of his family & that of the Gettys & Newsoms http://environmentalprogress.org/big-news/2018/1/11/jerry-browns-secret-war-on-clean-energy
How could they justify killing nuclear power plants while maintaining legitimacy as people who cared about the natural environment and air pollution?
Easy: by promoting renewables
Easy: by promoting renewables
California invested massively in renewables starting the 1970s with disastrous consequences
The solar farms were technical and economic failures and wastes of taxpayer investments. They were mostly abandoned
The wind turbines installed devastated hawk & eagle populations
The solar farms were technical and economic failures and wastes of taxpayer investments. They were mostly abandoned
The wind turbines installed devastated hawk & eagle populations
But secular, nature-loving people (eg Californians) can be easily tricked into thinking renewables are good for the environment because they are "natural"
This is the appeal-to-nature fallacy no different from buying food labeled "natural"
This is the appeal-to-nature fallacy no different from buying food labeled "natural"
And so @JerryBrownGov @GavinNewsom et al used renewables as public relations cover in order to kill the only technology, nuclear, that can replace fossil fuels, in large measure to protect their own family's oil monopoly, in addition to fear-mongering about nuclear for 40+ years.
Under Jerry Brown & Gavin Newsom, California's governors have focused like a laser on awarding renewables & battery contracts to friends & political allies while killing the state's last nuclear plants, San Onofre & Diablo Canyon
The implicit (& possibly explicit) deal that Team Brown/Newsom cut with PG&E & other utility executives is that PG&E can raise electricity rates & give themselves millions in bonuses in exchange for building renewables & shutting down their nuclear plants
It's not as though Newsom/Brown weren't warned of electricity wire forest fire danger. They were constantly warned! But they sided with extremist enviros who not only were obsessed with subsidizing renewables and killing nuclear plants but also opposed basic forest management.
And so, in exchange for electricity prices that rose SEVEN TIMES MORE than in rest of the U.S., we now are suffering BOTH dangerous fires AND black-outs!
How is @GavinNewsom & PG&E planning to deal with these problems?
By raising rates even higher!
How is @GavinNewsom & PG&E planning to deal with these problems?
By raising rates even higher!
How do you think that will go over?
Well, consider that polling shows just 28% of voters approve of the PG&E bail-out while 35% disapprove of it.
Seventy-eight percent of Californians (correctly) fear higher electricity prices will result. https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2019/09/03/why-california-may-go-nuclear/#52b27ce8ae02
Well, consider that polling shows just 28% of voters approve of the PG&E bail-out while 35% disapprove of it.
Seventy-eight percent of Californians (correctly) fear higher electricity prices will result. https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2019/09/03/why-california-may-go-nuclear/#52b27ce8ae02
Gov. @GavinNewsom appears to think he can spin, "brand," and bullshit his way out of everything from the fire disaster to the homelessness disaster to the housing crisis https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2019-10-21/newsom-gavin-affordable-housing-homeless-q-a
In mean just look at this:
"Q: During your inaugural speech, you called for a “Marshall Plan” on affordable housing. Have we gotten that?
"Newsom: We could brand it as such"
*Brand* it as such?
When Gavin talks I'm reminded of the book, "On Bullshit"
http://www2.csudh.edu/ccauthen/576f12/frankfurt__harry_-_on_bullshit.pdf
"Q: During your inaugural speech, you called for a “Marshall Plan” on affordable housing. Have we gotten that?
"Newsom: We could brand it as such"
*Brand* it as such?
When Gavin talks I'm reminded of the book, "On Bullshit"
http://www2.csudh.edu/ccauthen/576f12/frankfurt__harry_-_on_bullshit.pdf
It's not going to work
At some point, Californians are going to realize that they care more about having cheap and reliable electricity than making sacrifices to the sun gods & shutting down cheap & reliable plants for superstitious reasons masking a financial agenda.
At some point, Californians are going to realize that they care more about having cheap and reliable electricity than making sacrifices to the sun gods & shutting down cheap & reliable plants for superstitious reasons masking a financial agenda.
At some point, California news media will have to start reporting that it is the job of the governor to hold PG&E accountable, and that attempts by @GavinNewsom to evade responsibility are themselves a symptom of the culture of irresponsibility that pervades in Sacramento
How this for environmental sustainability?
Electricity is out for much of Nor. Calif.
PG&E won't even say when electricity will be turned back on for my neighborhood
My neighbor is running a loud, polluting diesel generator
I commuted to the office & emitted carbon doing so
Electricity is out for much of Nor. Calif.
PG&E won't even say when electricity will be turned back on for my neighborhood
My neighbor is running a loud, polluting diesel generator
I commuted to the office & emitted carbon doing so
I hope that these black-outs are a wake-up call, but I am not optimistic
We Californians are tolerant — too tolerant
We let self-medicating mentally ill people live/defecate/shoot drugs on street
We allow black-outs, corruption & incompetence
But even we have our limits
/END
We Californians are tolerant — too tolerant
We let self-medicating mentally ill people live/defecate/shoot drugs on street
We allow black-outs, corruption & incompetence
But even we have our limits
/END
